jstn

jstn:

petervidani:

“3D is antithetical to storytelling, where immersion in character is the goal. It constantly reminds you you’re watching a screen.” —Oliver Stapleton

I keep seeing this quote come across my dashboard, and I couldn’t disagree more. It sounds like something traditional theater people probably said when movies themselves were brand new. How can anyone single out any particular visual technique as “antithetical to storytelling”?

I believe him when he says he’s constantly reminded about watching a screen, though. I had a similar experience watching The Hobbit at 48 fps, but then my reason for being there was to evaluate the technology. I have a feeling a veteran cinematographer’s perception of 3D and high frame rate is going to be much different than for the younger kids I saw at the theater, kids who will never know a world without Nintendo 3DS and 4K digital projection.

I’m glad the world’s filmmakers (present and future) have uncharted waters to explore. I also wonder if it’s possible for any new storytelling technology to become transparent before it starts to be taken for granted. Let’s remember to ask those kids in a few years.

Predicted sidebar quote, 2052: “Holograms are antithetical to storytelling, it constantly reminds you you’re on a holodeck.”

Storytelling has and will continue to change. I think 3D film as it currently exists attempts to move cinema into a more encompassing, virtual world. I think that’s the goal, to make the viewer feel more a part of that world.

While I appreciate that goal, right now, it sucks. When I’m watching a movie in 3D with glasses, I don’t feel any more a part of that world. It’s a first step in that direction. I think the quote is accurate: right now, it detracts. But someday it won’t.

  1. krioboly reblogged this from kimoida
  2. kimoida reblogged this from philosofart
  3. moonpopsicle reblogged this from philosofart
  4. philosofart reblogged this from saracrow
  5. beethovensfifth reblogged this from lonelysandwich
  6. peridotwonder reblogged this from lonelysandwich
  7. cleo-nard reblogged this from futureoffilm
  8. tekniklr reblogged this from parislemon
  9. bbchase reblogged this from parislemon
  10. toothpickypicky reblogged this from petervidani
  11. latent-see reblogged this from fred-wilson
  12. alphamccoool reblogged this from futureoffilm
  13. absolutevideo reblogged this from futureoffilm
  14. karsen reblogged this from futureoffilm
  15. chungkings reblogged this from futureoffilm
  16. phunnaphat reblogged this from futureoffilm
  17. spasticalactica reblogged this from futureoffilm
  18. monster-rat reblogged this from waltergropius
  19. amoresophisticatedkrackel reblogged this from theladydalek